Doughnut Ice Cream Sandwiches At Holey Cream

If you care about calories, don’t step foot inside Holey Cream in Midtown. Doughnuts. Cupcakes. Ice cream. Cookies. Milkshakes. But I only came here for one thing: the Doughnut Ice Cream Sandwich ($7.25). Don’t expect to be in and out of this establishment in a couple of minutes if you choose to create your own doughnut. With close to 30 flavors of ice cream to choose from (plus sorbet and frozen yogurt) and a large selection of toppings, your mind will be boggling. I chose to go with a S’mores doughnut, which comes with a delectable marshmallow sauce, chocolate fudge and graham cracker crumbs. I don’t know what possessed me, but I thought that wasn’t enough and told the girl behind the counter to add heath bar bits on top. Then I picked out strawberry, milky way and homemade deep Belgian chocolate chip for my ice cream flavors. The chocolate one was so good I wished I had just gotten 3 scoops of that. My boyfriend went for the Cookies & Cream doughnut. The sheer size of these doughnut ice cream sandwiches will make your eyes pop out of your head. The first thing I said when she handed it to me was ‘How am I going to eat that?!’ The answer is, with a spoon and you will eat it all. Just don’t come here straight after dinner. You’re going to need extra room for all that goodness.